MR
Maya Reyes · 3rd+
VP Marketing @ Northbeam · Demand gen, brand & the messy bits in between
2h

We spent $94k on a campaign that converted exactly 6 people.

Here's the part I didn't say in the post-mortem deck.

The creative was good. The targeting was tight. The landing page tested clean.

So when it tanked, my first instinct was to blame the channel. "LinkedIn just doesn't work for us." Easy story. Lets everyone off the hook.

Then I actually called five people who clicked but didn't buy.

All five said a version of the same thing: "I didn't get what it actually does."

We'd written the whole campaign for people who already knew the category. Our messaging answered "why us?" — but our audience was still stuck on "what is this?"

We optimized the bottom of the funnel for an audience that was sitting at the top of it.

No amount of budget fixes a message aimed at the wrong stage of awareness.

The takeaway I keep taped to my monitor now:

Before you spend a dollar, write down what your audience already believes — not what you wish they believed. Then build the campaign from where they actually are.

The 6 conversions cost us $94k. The lesson was cheaper than the next campaign would've been.

What's the most expensive marketing assumption you've had to unlearn?

…more
👍 💡 👏 Aanya Kapoor and 1,283 others
214 comments · 47 reposts
Like
Comment
Repost
Send